Travel Agents in Multan Best Services in Multan Pakistan:
Best Travel Agents Services:
Regardless
of the low response rate, this process yielded a convenience sample of 19 Travel
Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best services] Agents in
Multan, Best Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best
services] agencies in Multan for best services agencies that clearly stood out
as self-reporting strong performers when compared against the assessment of
negative gross sales and revenues for the sector as a whole over that period
(personal communication, ASTA executives). As further revealed in Table 1, the
sample is diverse in terms of size and geographical location (see above).
In-depth interviews were conducted with top executives from each of these
agencies during the first half of 2006.
TABLE 1 Characteristics of Participating Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best services] Agents in Multan, Best Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best services] agencies in Multan for best services Agencies.
Interviews and Grounded Theory :
The semi-structured interviews took place in the work environment of the agencies and averaged one hour. With permission, all interviews were recorded to expedite communication and facilitate post-interview analysis. Topics were sent to the owners in advance and focused on a SWOT analysis, with the opportunities and threats components being applied to the sector as a whole rather than just the target agency. The strengths, applied to each individual agency, are reported in Weaver and Lawton (2008) and referred to below as warranted.
Underlying the study both conceptually and methodologically is grounded theory,
which harbors no preconceived notions about the relevant threats and
opportunities, but allows theory to emerge from the interview data as it is
systematically collected and analyzed (Glaser & Strauss, 1967, Glaser,
1998). Grounded theory methods yield ‘thick description’ of the target topic,
building the theory through a successive process of open coding (i.e.,
identifying basic categories and subcategories), axial coding (i.e.,
identifying apparent relationships among the categories and subcategories) and
selective coding (i.e., identifying core themes and their relationship to the
categories) as the interviewing process continues.
The probability of obtaining trustworthy outcomes in grounded theory is increased through constant comparison, wherein emerging patterns from previous interviews inform subsequent interviews to substantiate the relevance of those patterns (Decrop, 2004). In addition, sample diversity is desirable to increase the likelihood that all underlying themes and sub-themes emerge from the data. Also crucial is monitoring for theoretical saturation, which is the point when new interviews no longer yield new themes (McCracken, 1988).
If the 19 scheduled interviews did not produce theoretical saturation, then the authors were prepared to identify additional candidate agencies through laddering (i.e., asking interviewees for the names of owners of other highly successful Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best services] Agents in Multan, Best Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best services] agencies in Multan for best services agencies).
While no new themes
in fact emerged after the first 14 interviews, the remaining five interviews
were still valuable as sources of data/pattern enrichment. Within the field of
tourism studies, grounded theory is increasingly being employed as a
qualitative antidote to the limitations of survey-based quantitative research
(see for example Decrop & Snelders, 2005; Han & Mills, 2006; Jennings,
2005; Jordan & Gibson, 2004; Woodside, MacDonald, & Burford, 2004).
Opportunities:
The
external themes that emerged in relation to threats to the sector are
unfavorable public perceptions about conventional Travel Agents in Multan[Best
Travel agencies in Multan for best services] Agents in Multan, Best Travel
Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best services] agencies in
Multan for best services agencies, disadvantageous relations with some vendors,
and geopolitical and economic uncertainty. Illustrative interview excerpts are
provided, and the number following each is referenced against the identifiers
in Table 1. Threats are described first because of the tendency of the interviewees
to emphasize how these same threats could also be perceived as opportunities
and/or their proclivity to follow up discussions of threats with thoughts as to
what opportunities could be pursued by way of mitigation.
Unfavorable
Public Perceptions about Conventional Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel
agencies in Multan for best services] Agents in Multan, Best Travel Agents in
Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best services] agencies in Multan for
best services Agencies
Negative
perceptions about traditional Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in
Multan for best services] Agents in Multan, Best Travel Agents in Multan[Best
Travel agencies in Multan for best services] agencies in Multan for best
services agencies were by far the most common threat theme invoked by the
interviewed owners. Constituent sub-themes that contributed to these perceptions
were related to the role of the Internet as a viable competitor, the negative
impact of unqualified Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan
for best services] Agents in Multan, Best Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel
agencies in Multan for best services] agencies in Multan for best services
agents (e.g., those receiving qualifications through ‘card mills’), consistently
negative mass media coverage, and failure to attract young new agents.
The internet :
There
was consensus, not surprisingly, that quality traditional Travel Agents in
Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best services] Agents in Multan, Best
Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best services]
agencies in Multan for best services agencies provide value for money. However,
this was accompanied by a high level of concern that many consumers were
gravitating to the Internet to book their Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel
agencies in Multan for best services] Agents in Multan, Best Travel Agents in
Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best services] agencies in Multan for
best services under the allegedly erroneous impression that it provides a more
efficient and less expensive means for doing so:
“The
general public is under the impression that you can find lower fares on the
Internet, and I am not saying that that is not always true, but most of the
Internet sites that I have found … they still pull from the same fares that we
do.” (5)
“Our
biggest challenge really is the perception that there is not any value in using
a Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best services]
Agents in Multan, Best Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan
for best services] agencies in Multan for best services agency.” (2)
“…
every [study] has shown that the Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies
in Multan for best services] Agents in Multan, Best Travel Agents in
Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best services] agencies in Multan for
best services agencies do a better job. But the perception by the public is
that it's the opposite way around. So, we've got a big job ahead of us to make
sure that, for the kinds of business that we want to do, that people understand
that there's value there.” (12)
“…
the biggest weakness still is perception by the public.” (10)
“…
perception is 90% reality, that the Internet is cheaper.” (1)
The
owners without exception did concede that the Internet was useful for handling
simple bookings such as a single-leg airfare between two major airports:
“It
is a threat on the low end business; in fact, it has basically taken most of
the low end business.” (4)
However,
they were adamant that traditional agents are far more efficient and
cost-effective in arranging more complex modes of Travel Agents in Multan[Best
Travel agencies in Multan for best services] Agents in Multan, Best Travel
Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best services] agencies in
Multan for best services experience. The success of the cybermediaries in
attracting business was attributed by several owners to effective marketing
campaigns:
“They
[the cybermediaries] get these people so addicted, almost like they're drugged,
to the Internet that they convince these people that's the cheapest way to do
it.” (17)
Unqualified Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in
Multan for best services] agents
Public Services:
Negative public perceptions were also seen to be caused by a
proliferation of ‘Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for
best services] agents’ with questionable credentials obtained through so-called
‘card mills’. The latter are businesses that sell misleading identification
cards and training materials to individuals, giving the false impression that
the purchaser is a certified Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in
Multan for best services] agent entitled to discounts, airline upgrades, and/or
commissions from Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for
best services] suppliers that are normally reserved for legitimate Travel
Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best services] agents
(ASTA, 2005):
“The only thing they want to do is Travel Agents in
Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best services] at a discount – and if
you go on some of these fam [familiarization] trips where you have some of
these people on them, it's a whole different caliber. They're going for the
wrong reasons … I don't think they ought to be allowed to do that. I think it's
a dishonest business.” (14)
“It's the Mary Kay idea of ‘Come on board, and then go sell
your family and friends,’ you know. And, that's not really fair because now you
have somebody who is not trained, who has no knowledge of the destination,
who's not experienced – probably hasn't even been to that destination – out
there trying to sell their family and friends on places to go and places to be
…” (7)
Thus the unsuspecting public is dealing with poorly trained
and unprofessional Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for
best services] agents who are unlikely to hold any errors and omissions
insurance or surety bonds carried by professional Travel Agents in Multan[Best
Travel agencies in Multan for best services] agents to protect themselves,
suppliers and clients (Dickerson, 1997). Consumers who have bad experiences
with such agencies are attracted even more to the cybermediaries in so far as
many associate this poor quality of service with the Travel Agents in
Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best services] agency sector in
general. The long term consequences are indicated in the following quote:
“… in the short run it besmirches the reputation of all Travel
Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best services] agencies,
and it dents our professionalism, but in the long run, it will take those
people that have been burnt by those [unqualified] home-based agencies, and
take them out of the Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for
best services]ing [through conventional agencies] pool …” (6)
The owners felt that this problem could be overcome to some
extent by ensuring that the credentials of reputable agencies are clearly
differentiated from those associated with the card mills. However, this
solution was thought to be limited by the fact that most Americans are
unfamiliar with Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in Multan for best
services] agency-related criteria, and more generally do not recognize agents
as professionals in the same sense as doctors, lawyers or engineers.
Mass media coverage
Many owners believe that the mass media contributes to
negative public image, sometimes directly through negative coverage of
conventional agencies:
“The main problem that we have as an industry is the
perception that the new media or the press continues to give us. They will
never report a good story, they will always report the negatives … do you ever
hear anything really positive about shopping at a Travel Agents in Multan[Best
Travel agencies in Multan for best services] agency?” (2)
This sometimes involves on-line media coverage of the
cybermediators:
“Well, the media for one [is a threat]. It is just every
time you hear anyone, any guru out there is always talking about the Internet,
it kind of writes us off.” (4)More prevalent is indirect negative publicity
generated by saturated and sensationalist coverage of unusual events associated
with strategically critical suppliers such as the cruise lines. Examples
include the 2006 Star Princess cigarette fire which quickly spread smoke
throughout the entire ship, resulting in one fatality, another eleven passenger
injuries, and damage to 150 cabins (Lim, 2006), the 70-foot high rogue wave
which smashed into Norwegian Caribbean Line's Norwegian Dawn on its return trip
from the Bahamas (Lemire, 2005); and unexplained cruise passenger
disappearances (Topham, 2007):
“Unfortunately, you see 20/20 and somebody has pushed
somebody off the back of a ship. And then the poor guy at RCCL gets interviewed
and they want to know why cruising is so dangerous.” (4)
While owners were referring mainly to traditional mass media
outlets, several mentioned the role of online Travel Agents in Multan[Best
Travel agencies in Multan for best services] sites and blogs in conveying bad
reviews of products (e.g., hotels) that may or may not be warranted.
Failure to attract the young
Many of the owners were concerned that negative public
perceptions were discouraging promising young school-leavers and budding
entrepreneurs from entering the Travel Agents in Multan[Best Travel agencies in
Multan for best services] agency field, and that the industry was doing nothing
to address this situation:
“There's no new blood getting into the business …” (8)
“You know, the young people are going to have to take over
the industry. If we're not trying to attract them, then there's not going to be
anyone to do it.” (10)
One owner implicated the higher education system for
encouraging negative attitudes:
“We just recently hired a young girl from University ‘x’ who
majored in Tourism and Hospitality. Her professors gave her no hope for this
particular job. You know, go work for the hotels, go work for this, go work for
that, but there is no future here.” (2)
A variant in this sub-theme is the belief that the few young
‘Gen-X and Y’ entrants who are attracted tend to lack enthusiasm, a strong work
ethic, and sense of commitment, which thereby threatens to erode the quality of
the work force and the capacity of agencies to become more successful and
expand:
“If we could get good personnel who would really stick with
us, we'd be ten times the size as we are now. We would be the biggest and the
best going … we just don't have the workforce to support it.” (15)
For more info about best travel agents and top agencies Multan Pakistan - Click Below
No comments:
Post a Comment